NEW YORK, United States — Two weeks after the end of the Chinese New Year holiday period, specially designed festive items sat unsold at uncharacteristically tranquil boutiques on New York’s Fifth Avenue. According to staff at several stores who spoke to BoF on the condition of anonymity, Chinese customer numbers had noticeably decreased in the wake of a travel downturn caused by the coronavirus outbreak.
“It’s going to be horrible” for the travel and travel retail industries, predicts David Tarsh, a spokesman for travel analysis firm ForwardKeys. According to the firm’s recently released figures, outbound travel from China fell by 57.5 percent in the three week period after the imposition of government travel restrictions. Flight bookings for March and April combined are currently 55.9 percent of what they were at the same time in 2019, but that number will probably go down, according to Tarsh.
“It’s quite possible that by the time we get to the beginning of March, it’s even worse. Given the progress of the disease, it’s more likely we’ll see the trend of cancellations continuing,” he adds.
First and foremost a human tragedy, the crisis has industry leaders expressing their concern for China.
The combination of travel restrictions, cancelled flights, and broader travel anxiety means that retailers beyond China are now feeling the effects of a public health emergency that has claimed the lives of 2126 people. China’s domestic retail sector has already been hit in a profound way, as the coronavirus outbreak has impacted all areas of the Chinese economy, with ratings agency Moody’s recently revising its Chinese GDP growth forecast for 2020 to 5.2 percent, down from 5.8 percent.
First and foremost a human tragedy, the crisis has industry leaders expressing their concern for China which remains the epicentre of the crisis. “It’s very difficult for people to understand the scale of disruption to daily life in China and the resilience of people in the face of this epidemic and the measures that have been imposed to stop the spread of the infection,” says Andrew Keith, president of luxury department store group Lane Crawford, which has stores in Hong Kong, Beijing, Shanghai and Chengdu.
“Cities have been locked down, people are scared, and are focused on survival. The basic necessities of daily life — food and personal care staples, and the ability to go out, socialise with friends and relatives — have become luxuries.”
Severe Travel Slowdown
The latest statistics from the International Civil Aviation Organisation show that around 70 airlines have cancelled all flights to and from mainland China, and 50 more have cut back on flight numbers. Beyond China, it estimates that Japan’s tourism sector will be hit the hardest, with a prediction that it will lose US$1.29 billion in the first quarter of 2020.
Chinese travellers took 166 million outbound trips in 2019, according to the China Tourism Academy, making China the world’s largest source market for tourists. What’s more, Chinese consumers account for an estimated one-third of all global luxury purchases, according to Bain & Company, with 73 percent of that spending taking place outside mainland China. Now, with international leisure trips virtually at a standstill, retailers dependent on the Chinese traveller market are feeling the effects around the world.
Augustin de Romanet, chief executive of Groupe ADP (the French international airport operator), told investors in a February 14 earnings conference call that that the coronavirus could have a “real material” impact at Paris’ two airports. He stated that the airports see 2 million passengers from China per year, which accounts for 15 percent of total spending.
The repercussions are enormous... not only for airlines, tourism sites, and hotels but for the luxury industry as a whole.
“If by the end of March, the coronavirus subsides and flights from China resume, we can absorb that. However, if it continues in April and May, this is going to affect us, and we will have to draw the conclusions from that in our forecast,” he said.
“The repercussions are enormous,” says Chloe Reuter, founding partner of Shanghai-based Reuter Communications, “not only for airlines, tourism sites, and hotels but for the luxury industry as a whole, which had come to rely on the ever-growing number of Chinese looking to purchase luxury items.”
The slowdown in travel has also spread to outbound tourists from neighbouring countries. Last week “was the first time we saw travel retail impacted outside of China,” says Tarsh, with outbound bookings from Asia-Pacific locations excluding mainland China and Hong Kong seeing a 10.5 percent decrease.
Earlier this month, Singapore’s Transport Minister Khaw Boon Wan said that where Chinese tourists account for a third of retail sales in Changi Airport, “the one-third has evaporated.”
Duty Free and Outlet Sectors
The travel retail channels likely to be hit especially hard are duty-free and off-price outlets which rely heavily on outbound Chinese travellers.
The travel retail industry “is acutely aware of its potentially huge impact on the industry’s commercial performance,” says Alison Farrington, the associate editor for Duty Free News International, noting that “several duty free retailers, airports and cruise lines have put in place preventative measures such as travel restrictions and store closures” that are “painful decisions commercially,” yet necessary.
While store closings are still concentrated in mainland China, disruptions to retail operations have occurred in neighbouring markets which attract duty free shoppers from the mainland: South Korea’s top retailers Shilla, Lotte, and Shinsegae have all reduced their opening hours, and Shilla closed its Seoul and Jeju stores from February 3 to 7.
The travel retail channels likely to be hit especially hard are duty-free and off-price outlets.
It is difficult to overstate the importance of outbound Chinese travellers to these retailers. Chinese customers accounted for a third of global duty-free sales in 2018, according to Morgan Stanley. More than half of Chinese visitors to the UK are estimated to visit luxury retail outlet Bicester Village, while McArthurGlen has previously stated that Chinese travellers represent a third of total international spending at its locations.
According to the World Health Organisation (WHO), there have been 75,724 cases of the coronavirus across 27 countries, although most have been in China. According to yesterday’s briefing from the Director General of the WHO, Tedros Adhanom, "The data from China appears to show a decline in new cases. This is welcome news, but it must be interpreted very cautiously. It’s far too early to make predictions about this outbreak."
Brand Executives Take Stock
“It’s like a ghost town,” said a salesperson at the counter of one French luxury beauty brand in a Fifth Avenue department store, who asked not to be named as she was not authorised to represent the brand on the record. “Just look around,” she said, pointing to the nearly empty beauty floor.
Brands are bracing for the worst of the travel downturn. Burberry stated in an official update on February 7 that “the spending patterns of Chinese customers in Europe and other tourist destinations have been less impacted to date but given widening travel restrictions, we anticipate these to worsen over the coming weeks.”
Estée Lauder’s fiscal year 2020 second-quarter earnings release stated that “global travel retail, localities most affected by the virus outbreak, and destination markets favoured by tourists are expected to experience the greatest negative impact in the coming months followed by a gradual recovery later in the fiscal year.”
Jean-Paul Agon, chairman and chief executive of L’Oréal, said that the decrease “will have a temporary impact on the beauty market in the region and therefore on our business in China and travel retail in Asia, even if it is too early to assess it.”
The outbreak is having a wide-ranging effect on fashion, as closed factories have disrupted supply chains and companies.
According to Fitch Solutions, brands that have the most exposure to Chinese customers will be the hardest hit. It cites Hong Kong as one of the worst off as Chinese nationals made up over 78 percent of visitors in 2019, even as their numbers dropped due to political upheaval. “About half of Chinese outbound tourists are actually travelling to Hong Kong and Macau, which are practically closed to Chinese tourists,” says Wolfgang Arlt, the chief executive of the China Outbound Tourism Research Institute.
“While the current situation is unprecedented with months of social unrest in Hong Kong followed by an epidemic across Greater China, we have experienced both, separately, previously and we will be prepared to do so should a situation arise again,” said Lane Crawford’s Keith in a statement, referring to the SARS epidemic which hit the region from 2002 to 2004.
Keith added that the department store is “not as exposed as other businesses to the fluctuation of mainland tourists because we have a very strong, loyal customer base.” He does note, however, that online sales are picking up as people refrain from travel. “What we are seeing overall is an even greater reliance on e-commerce in China,” he says. “We’ve seen a triple digit spike online in our Lane Crawford China business.”
However, it is a mixed picture for e-commerce. Alibaba Chief Executive Daniel Zhang, warned that the coronavirus will dampen business “across the board” for the company in the first three months of 2020, including Tmall and Taobao.
The outbreak is having a wide-ranging effect on fashion, as closed factories have disrupted supply chains and companies including Burberry, Tapestry Inc., and Capri Holdings have released revised sales outlooks. Events both inside and outside of China are being cancelled, including Shanghai Fashion Week, and some international trade shows.
Recovery Based on Pent Up Demand
The outlook for a rebound remains unclear, with many industry stakeholders taking an optimistic tone for now.
“The April-May period is always slow,” says Sage Brennan, co-founder of China Luxury Advisors, who notes that even the Chinese New Year travel period is “nothing like the summer or even Golden Week in October” in terms of visitor numbers and spending. He predicts that when people do start traveling again, it is “going to recover quickly” because the Chinese government will likely invest in spurring travel and there will be pent up consumer demand for travel.
Alexander Glos of Shanghai-based travel marketing agency i2i Group says, “We anticipate a substantial amount of pent up demand because many people did not travel during Chinese New Year,” saying that his company’s data indicates rebookings are taking place for April through June. “Speaking to several travel resellers in China during the past week, they actually are very optimistic that business will not only come back, but that actually the business over the medium term will be very robust.”
The outlook for a rebound remains unclear, with many industry stakeholders taking an optimistic tone for now.
“We are quite optimistic that outbound travel will quickly rebound after this crisis,” says Shanghai-based communications firm WE Red Bridge Managing Director and Head of Strategy Nicky Wang, who notes that the firm has seen an increase in search volume for Chinese Labour Day travel at the start of May. The firm formerly counted luxury outlet village player Value Retail as a client in China.
But analysts remind retailers to keep a more cautious outlook. Predictions right now about when exactly the crisis will abate are “mighty speculative,” says Tarsh. “At this stage, we truly don’t know what’s going to happen with this viral outbreak.”
Brands’ marketing efforts for now are likely to switch focus to other traveller markets. “This is a moment to fill the void by studying alternative origin markets and focusing promotional efforts on them,” says Olivier Ponti, the vice president of insights for ForwardKeys.
This does not mean ignoring China, but rather taking a step back from commercialised messaging in the Chinese market for the time being, says Reuter. “While now is not the time for active promotion, it is a time for active involvement,” she explains, by highlighting the donations made by the world’s leading luxury and beauty conglomerates to charities and hospitals. When it comes to Chinese tourists, she says brands and tourism boards should also “ensure that they remain sensitive to the situation and offer empathetic messages, otherwise it could risk having a longterm adverse effect,” especially amid reports of xenophobic incidents worldwide.
“When this is over, I think people will want to celebrate life. They’ll fall in love again with beautiful things and crave social experiences that have meaning and make them feel good about themselves, and they will want to travel after being isolated,” says Keith, who notes that the same happened after the SARS crisis. For now, the question is whether that will happen later rather than sooner.
Updated 14:37 GMT on February 27 2020: This story misstated that Value Retail is a client of WE Red Bridge. Value Retail used to be a client of WE Red Bridge in mainland China.
FASHION & BEAUTY
Chinese Fashion Store Leaves Emotional Message on Paris Streets
Shanghai-based concept store, ENG, known for its support of Chinese fashion labels – including Angel Chen, Private Policy, Sankuanz and Uma Wang – left a message on the streets of Paris this week, plastering thousands of posters in the centre of the city with the slogan “I am not a virus.” It was, they say, in response to anti-Asian racism that has risen in conjunction with the coronavirus outbreak. (ENG Official)
Chanel Burned for a Second Time as Beijing Show Postponed
Less than six months since it announced the cancellation of a Hong Kong cruise show in the wake of political unrest there, Chanel has announced the postponement of its upcoming Métiers d’Art re-showing in Beijing, due to concerns about China’s coronavirus outbreak. Despite the double stroke of bad fortune, the brand plans to double down on its splashy show strategy. (BoF)
TECH & INNOVATION
E-commerce in China Hit Hard by Coronavirus
While brick and mortar stores are obviously suffering the impact of the full or partial quarantine of more than 700 million people in China, the country’s e-commerce sphere is also struggling. Essentials and grocery purchases are up, but almost every other category is down, with logistics networks under immense strain from quarantine restrictions and workers unable or unwilling to return to work. (Technode)
China’s Tech Giants Build Health Monitoring Apps
Whenever there is a need in China, it seems tech giants Alibaba and Tencent appear ready to fulfil it. In the wake of the coronavirus outbreak and varying levels of quarantine in place in different Chinese cities and provinces, both companies are working with local governments to roll out health monitoring apps that help decide who is safe to return to work, or even leave their home. (The Wall Street Journal)
CONSUMER & RETAIL
Costco Sets Sights on Second Shanghai Store
Costco has been something of a surprise hit on the Chinese retail scene, attracting hordes to its first Shanghai store even as other foreign retailers flail. Now it has its sights set on a second location, paying $128 million for a 40-year lease on a tract of land located by the Shanghai Disney Resort. (Shine)
Wanda Group Takes It Online
Facing a dramatic decline in foot traffic, one of China’s largest department store groups has brought 60,000 of its stores online using WeChat mini-programs and partnering with JD.com (also aligned with WeChat owner Tencent) for logistical assistance. (China Fashion Group)
POLITICS, ECONOMY, SOCIETY
Spring Festival Travel Drop Confirmed
Though it should come as no surprise that Chinese travel during the most recent Spring Festival holidays fell due to the coronavirus health emergency, official data now paints a picture of how much – 45 percent, with no post-Festival bump in sight. (Xinhua)
Chinese Government Flags Belt-Tightening on the Horizon
In an article affiliated with the Chinese Communist Party’s Central Committee, Finance Minister Liu Kun has sent a clear signal that the government will not stimulate its economy by rolling out a massive monetary stimulus. Instead, he writes, “policies and capital must be used in a more effective, precise and targeted way.” (Reuters)
China Decoded wants to hear from you. Send tips, suggestions, complaints and compliments to our Shanghai-based Asia Correspondent firstname.lastname@example.org.